Haha
I feel like Paula Abdul on American Idol, all gushing.
I love the concept, but after leaving the homepage, the magic is gone.
Like Dom says, carry the theme throughout the site, not just a little nav at the top, perhaps adding some better fonts and an off-white background (old paper with charred edged?) that won’t compete with the text.
The yellow is in sharp contrast with the theme. A real turn-off.