Thats ok, I seen you had stated it wasnt really scraping, just wanted voice my opinion that we needed to be careful with that terminology.
Layouts/templates are a dime a dozen, unless its something ground breaking that is totally unique to just one site, I doubt a simple layout would be protected by copyright laws.
I had looked at the coding, it was different. Both used shades of greens, but the colors are different, the graphics were different. The logos are similar but not the same; heck look at CAPS spring break logo; it too was inspired by another very well known logo.
I do agree the webmaster could have done a better job choosing his layout and color scheme, but calling him a thief might be going a bit far, he is simply an idiot in my opinion.