What excellent posts BB. I think you have vocalised what we all feel and put foward a great idea.
We partially discussed this at dinner (time constraints suck) with Prof, Talkcasinos and Craps R Us the other night and to date this and posting/reading posts has been the only way to get a handle on what is working for who.
It still makes no sense as to works for whom, but a monthly little run down by everyone would be a very powerful tool indeed.
I have been leaning a lot towards relying on stats for various sites and using for comparison purposes.
We all KNOW something is very amiss. Time to put the finger on the pulse.