Hi there,
Overall Site Layout:
Colors: As others have stated already, black is not always beautiful on websites. But there are exceptions: I am not sure why, but it looks ok to me with the dark green frame.
The Boxes: Great, definitely stay with the small ones I’d say. But be careful, if you plan to add more categories.
The Fonts: Clear font with no bells and whistles – works perfectly to give your site a sound, unbiased look and feel.
Concept:
It’s a nice idea to involve the readers with the site. People will come back and see what other people think about sites they rated. Longer term, maybe you should think about a way to provide some kind of incentive to the review writers (something like ranks maybe? But then again, that does not work too well with the anonymous ratings..)
Content:
To date, and I am probably stating the obvious here, you have too few entries in the non-“poker sites” categories.
The “Suggest a Site” option should be a web-form in my opinion.
Good Luck!
My 2 Small Blinds Worth…
Freeroller