Classics – I think its safe to say that the results are all dependent on how things are done etc.
I guess with SEO, blanket all encompassing statements are meaningless because there are hundreds of different scenarios.
I agree that recips are “natural” to a degree, but this has been abused too and then it becomes unatural. Agreed that linking to something is a “vote” for a site because it has value, but again, this is often not the case.
If I was to recommend a link technique to a client (if I took clients) it would be simple: Make it look natural. Combine recip links with one ways. Keep the partners themed and maybe throw in the odd non themed link as well. Randomness is less likely to be contrived as a scheme.
BTW – do you think that PR in itself has any real value? I do not know for sure, but dont think this is the case anymore. I think PR by itself is dead.
We have probably debated this topic enough. Thanks for you input!