Ok guys this is an interesting discussion and so far its stayed on the high grounds.
Heres my two cents:
1.) CAP was created for us as affiliates to share information about the programs we work with and the industry in general. This includes both Good things (what works, site reviews, link exchanges, SEO techniques, Jokes and life experiences) and Bad things (who we believe may be shaving us, which PPCs are totally full of crap and whos wildly underperforming all the other casinos we promote). CAP is all about the EXCHANGE of information and ideas and as long as I am here it will continue to have that as its prime focus.
2.) We have no problem with controversial discussions as long as they remain business oriented and professional.
3) If you have legitimate issues with a program and data to support the claim you are encouraged to bring it foward to work towards a resolution. That’s the KEY POINT we want to focus on problem RESOLUTION and not make it a place where we just batter people for no reason other then revenge or to do damage to an individual or business.
4) In private areas we are more liberal in our discussions and I generally won’t intercede unless we get so carried away it’s no longer moving forward in a beneficial way for the participants or community.
Now with all that being said I will let you guys continue to discuss this if you wish. Just don’t get rumpled feathers or make it a personality issue. It’s an adult business discussion.
Personally I have no problem with you discussing things privately. If you have a problem with a program or want to report an issue without going public I think PMing others or emailing them with your concerns is fine and I do it myself.
I understand Dom’s concern and I agree that we shouldnt tar and feather a program, even in private, without reasonable cause. (With reasonable cause I say let em have it 
)
I also agree with her that its prudent to take everything you do hear with a grain of salt as some programs do perform better for one individual then another.
Have fun guys I am going out with Mrs Professor for the evening. Stay out of trouble.