The appraisal was done by an unbiased 3rd party, specializing in evaluating domain value in the resale market.
I doubt there are any remaining http://www.onlinecasino.xxx domains available at present. As soon as a new suffix is presented to the market, top casino urls are generally preordered, before the public has access to them. If you truly purchased yours for $35, then you definetly made a great investment.